|
"In an age where narrow
definitions and reductionist labels divide the Body of Christ and breed
conflict within congregations, Tony is an articulate proponent of "the
third way," helping congregations to discover common identity and
purpose in the mission of creating and sustaining lives of authentic
Christian discipleship. Tony models the servant-leadership he espouses,
listening carefully and speaking humbly. He brings to his work not only
knowledge and experience, but genuine wisdom."
John T. McFadden |


|
Posted
August 30, 2010:
 |
Autumn is in the air.
The nights are cooler. Some maples are showing early color. The
cat is seeking the indoors more often. Spiders are everywhere.
An article in the Seattle Times said the annual arachnid
invasion is not because spiders are seeking warmth; it's that
legions of spiders hatched in the spring have now grown up, are
needing larger web sites, and are on the prowl for mates.
Whatever the cause, the hanging webs of orb-weavers across every
path and doorway seems to accompany autumn here in the
Northwest.
|
 |
Another sign of the season
is, of course, school opening. But will they open? A
school principal of my acquaintance is hard at the task of
getting ready for a new school year. Will schools open on
schedule on September 8 or will there be a teacher's strike?
Seattle School District teachers vote Thursday on their new
contract. Independent evaluations of the respective contract
proposals of the SEA (teacher's union) and SSD (School District)
find the latter serious and substantive, the former defensive
and temporizing. A strike in the current climate seems both
unwise and unlikely.
|
 |
A great article in the
August 10 edition of The Christian Century by Kenda Creasy Dean,
"Faith, Nice and Easy: the Almost Christian Formation of Teens."
Working off the results of a national study on youth and
religion, Dean finds that what many churches offer youth (and
themselves) is a thin "Moralistic, Therapeutic Deism." Here's
Dean: "We 'teach' young people baseball, but we 'expose' them to
faith. We provide coaching and opportunities for youth to
develop and improve their pitches and their SAT scores, but we
blithely assume that religious identity will happen by osmosis
and will emerge 'when youth are ready' (a confidence we
generally lack when it comes to, say, algebra)."
|
 |
Later in her article Dean
uses a phrase I love, "God's preferential option for the
unlikely." Dean: "God calls people not for what they
have but for what they lack. Empty hands receive, empty wombs
are filled, empty tombs proclaim resurrection--and the unformed
selves of adolescents make room for Christ in ways that are
difficult for adults' hardened, formed egos."
|
 |
The notion of God's
preferential option for the unlikely could be the basis of a
theology for the small church. One event I'm doing this
fall, on Long Island on October 18, is particularly for smaller
membership congregations. God, after all, chose "tiny" Bethlehem
as the place of the Savior's birth, not big Jerusalem.
|
 |
Our Congregational
Leadership Northwest "Conversation about Writing and the
Pastoral Life," held last week proved to be delightful.
My angle of approach was vocational. Is a part of your pastoral
call a call to write? One of the many things pastors have to
offer, whether in sermons or published writing, is their
awareness of life's messiness and mystery. Where much
contemporary media labels and puts people in boxes, clergy are
constantly encountering the ways that people, actual people, are
more surprising, elusive and interesting.
|
 |
Next up for CLN is a
"Workshop on Congregational Purpose and Vision." So
many congregations seems to find it difficult to develop or
maintain a sense of direction. Lacking a reasonably clear sense
of direction, congregations often fall prey to chronic conflict
and to congregational factions (or even noisy individuals) that
cry out loudly for attention to their needs or agendas. This
workshop will be held on Saturday, October 9, 8:30 to noon at
Rainier Beach Presbyterian in southeast Seattle. For more info
and to register go to
www.clnorthwest.org or click on "Learning Opportunities" on
my homepage.
|
 |
I made my debut as a sports
columnist this week, with a piece for Crosscut.com on the
abysmal state of Seattle sports (except for the women's NBA
team, the Storm). Like Seattle itself, the Mariners and Seahawks
seem to be leadership averse. Or at least that was my argument.
See for yourself. Go to Crosscut.com.
|
 |
Pondering the Mosque
controversy last week I happened on this from philosopher Josef
Pieper: "The place of authentic reality is taken over
by infectious reality." While people were arguing for and
against the Ground Zero Mosque, a Seattle cartoonist, Molly
Norris, was in hiding and under FBI protection because a Muslim
cleric in Yemen has called for her to be killed. Who knew that
being a cartoonist was such a dangerous occupation? Pete Jackson
wrote about this for Crosscut. In my denomination people are
rushing to show their good will toward Islam by reading from the
Koran in services and the like. But no one I know is talking
about the plight of Molly Norris.
|
 |
Enjoy the waning days of
August and the early days of September. Grace and
peace, |
- Tony Robinson
Posted
August 23, 2010:
 |
I am back home, in
Seattle, after my six week sojourn in the Wallowa Mountains,
providing support for my elderly mother as she summered at her
cabin there. She has returned to her home, with my sister, in
Lynden, Washington. The Wallowas are a stunningly beautiful and
historically/ cultural fascinating area, one to which our family
has deep connections. But I am glad to be home. Given the amount
of travel I already do for work, six weeks away was a long
stretch.
|
 |
My Crosscut piece, last week, on
the acquisition of University Baptist's property and buildings
by Seattle's Mars Hill Church got a lot of readership and
response. You can click on it here:
http://crosscut.com/2010/August/17/religion/20069/A-tale-of-two-churches:-Mars-Hill-vs.-University-Baptist/.
|
 |
Some of the response, both
on-line and directly to me, asked if I thought liberal churches
have a future at all and would I comment? Of course,
most of my 33 year ministry, ten books, and hundreds of
articles, and far too many sermons all are addressed to those
questions and to what I think historically liberal congregations
need to be doing to have a present and a future.
|
 |
There are no simple
answers to such questions. Part of the problem is with
"liberalism" itself, which has become arrogant, complacent and
intellectually moribund. Related to that, "liberal theology,"
has lost energy, direction and substance. Simply repeating
"inclusive, diverse, and justice," does not a theology make. I
certainly do think liberal or moderate or mainline churches can
have a future, but not without some serious questioning of basic
assumptions, real housecleaning, and new seriousness about
Christian faith/ theology and leadership.
|
 |
In a way related to this
is preacher and teacher of preachers, Tom Long's, recent book,
"Preaching from Memory to Hope," which I've just read.
Long takes the measure of much contemporary mainline preaching,
which lacks both passion and conviction. He does a great job of
assessing what he calls the "gnostic impulse," expressed in the
work of such fellow travelers as Elaine Pagels, Karen Armstrong,
Marcus Borg, Bart Ehrmann, John Shelby Spong and Robert Funk. (A
common denominator among many of these is that they are former
fundamentalists who have swung from one extreme to another.)
|
 |
Long's chapter, "Meeting
Marcus Borg Again for the First Time," is alone worth the price
of admission. Preachers in many mainline churches
should consider a sermon series on the work of these figures and
the "gnostic impulse," being careful to be as restrained and yet
forthright as Long is.
|
 |
One sign of the mainline's
problem is that most clergy (and churches) are preoccupied with
directing their fire, such as it is, against the religious right
or conservatives (often cartoon versions of them),
while failing to recognize that the really important challenges
are coming from, one wants to say "the left," but that's not
really the right term for Armstrong, Borg, Spong, et. al. It is
more of a new gnosticism, with some Pelagius thrown in.
Entertaining for intellectuals, but not at all helpful to the
church or faithful witness.
|
 |
All of this is complicated
by the culture wars, which make us stupid. The current
raging battle front there is the so-called "Ground Zero Mosque."
This issue, like so many of the culture war issues, is more a
media creation, and specifically a Fox News Corp. creation, than
anything else. It reminds me of the Jeremiah Wright controversy
of spring 2008, which was also largely a creation of Fox.
|
 |
I thought Frank Rich's
column in yesterday's (8/22/2010) New York Times, pointing out
that this raging attack on Islam here at home makes the military
effort in Afghanistan doubly hard quite right. Afghan
and Iraqi Muslims are supposed to believe we really care about
their nations and cultures while Islamaphobia is on such vivid
display here?
|
 |
Related to this (somehow)
were last week's news reports indicating that 20% of Americans
believe President Obama is a Muslim. I wonder how that
percentage correlates to the viewership of Fox and the listenership to Limbaugh and the like? My hunch is that this
audience would be equally surprised to discover that the
majority of the world's Christians are not Caucasian but
African, Asian and Hispanic. One thing I notice on my forays
into middle and rural America are that Fox is the default
network of choice in many bars, hotels, restaurants and the
like. One recalls the acid phrase of William Dean Howells, "No
artist ever starved by underestimating the taste of the American
public."
|
 |
Ah well, may the closing weeks of
August bring you ripe blueberries, colorful zinnias, a good
sermon or two, and love. Grace and peace.
|
- Tony Robinson
|
|
HOME |
PERSONAL SKETCH |
WHAT'S TONY THINKING
REFERENCES |
CONTACT |
KEYNOTE SPEAKER AND PREACHER
CONSULTANT AND COACH |
AUTHOR |
COLUMNIST |
TEACHER
UPCOMING
ENGAGEMENTS |
LEARNING
OPPORTUNITIES
Copyright © 2010 Anthony B. Robinson
Website created by
IlluminAge |
|
 |





 |